In the previous episode, I presented the Decreto di Citazione Diretta a Giudizio (Decree of Direct Summons to Trial), signed on October 28, 2022, by prosecutor Antonia Giammaria of the Rome Public Prosecutor's Office.
The document demonstrated that the criminal proceedings initiated following a complaint filed by Eni in 2018 continued to move forward, despite the clearly irregular service of notice carried out directly in Brazil, without using the formal international judicial cooperation mechanisms between the two countries.
But what did the Italian prosecutor write about me in that document?
In bringing charges of aggravated defamation under Article 595, paragraph 3, of the Italian Criminal Code, the Public Prosecutor's Office alleged that I had repeatedly published derogatory messages about Eni through enisway.com, a blog, and various social media platforms.
According to the prosecution, my publications contained allegedly false information, accompanied by comments and images concerning purported unlawful conduct by the company and its executives.
The document also expressly mentioned my position as founder and president of the Brazilian Institute of Ethics in Business (Instituto Brasileiro de รtica nos Negรณcios).
In other words, the prosecutor turned my publications and allegations of wrongdoing involving Eni into elements of a criminal accusation.
It is essential to clarify that these statements appeared in a charging document. At that time, they did not constitute findings established by a criminal conviction.
But the story took an even more troubling turn.
๐ Eni used this document from the criminal proceedings in the second civil lawsuit it had filed against me in Italy.
And there is a particularly significant circumstance: according to the court records I have been examining, that civil lawsuit was already at an advanced stage, approaching the issuance of a judgment.
๐น Why submit to a civil judge a document containing accusations made by the Public Prosecutor's Office in separate judicial proceedings?
๐น What was the purpose of bringing those allegations to the judge's attention at precisely that moment?
The issue is not merely the document's content.
It is also the timing of its submission and the possibility that criminal charges not yet adjudicated were used to strengthen Eni's position in a civil dispute.
Italian civil procedure establishes deadlines for submitting documents and evidence, as well as safeguards intended to ensure that both parties have an opportunity to challenge the evidence presented.
For this reason, I consider it essential to clarify whether the submission complied with the applicable procedural rules and whether my defense was given an effective opportunity to challenge its contents.
An accusation made by the Public Prosecutor's Office does not, in itself, constitute proof of the facts alleged against the accused.
And the submission of that accusation in separate judicial proceedings raises questions that cannot be ignored:
๐ On what date did Eni submit the criminal summons decree to the court in the second civil lawsuit?
๐ Was the document submitted after the procedural stage for presenting documents and evidence had closed?
๐ Did the judge authorize its submission and ensure that the defense had an opportunity to challenge it?
๐ Did the civil judge take the Italian prosecutor's allegations into account when issuing the judgment?
These questions must be examined in light of the court records and Italian procedural law.
What I find particularly serious is the possibility that allegations originating from criminal proceedings, whose international service of judicial notice had already been questioned, were used to strengthen Eni's position in another lawsuit against the same whistleblower.
Could this have been a way of turning a criminal accusation into an instrument of influence over a civil judgment?
I do not present this question as an established judicial finding, but as an issue that deserves a truly independent, impartial, and transparent investigation.
After all, when a major corporation files multiple lawsuits against someone who reported irregularities in its operations, it is legitimate to examine not only each case individually, but also how those proceedings relate to one another.
JUSTICE MUST BE ADMINISTERED ON THE BASIS OF ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE, RESPECT FOR THE RIGHT TO CHALLENGE EVIDENCE, AND PROCEDURAL SAFEGUARDS — NOT THE INSTITUTIONAL WEIGHT OF THOSE BRINGING AN ACCUSATION.
For almost 25 years, I have maintained that documentary truth must prevail over narratives constructed to discredit the whistleblower.
And the events presented this week raise questions that still demand answers.
๐ด ENI SHOULD AUTHORIZE A TRULY INDEPENDENT, IMPARTIAL, AND TRANSPARENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE FLINTO CASE!
๐ท IN THE NEXT EPISODE — MONDAY, NOVEMBER 23: We will return to the Good Offices conducted by the Brazilian National Contact Point for the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises.
After so many developments, a new action by Eni would cause surprise and disbelief, calling into question the expectations built throughout that process.
What could possibly have happened?
❎ Learn more:
1️⃣ Rome Public Prosecutor's Office — Decreto di Citazione Diretta a Giudizio (October 28, 2022):
๐น Original document
๐น English translation

No comments:
Post a Comment