π December 2021 – January 2022 | Brazil — Italy
π· Is it possible to negotiate a consensual resolution with a multinational company while that very same company initiates criminal proceedings against you in another country?
That was precisely the situation I faced during the Good Offices conducted by Brazil's National Contact Point (NCP Brazil), under the OECD - OCDE Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises.
While Eni was participating in a mediation process aimed at reaching a consensual resolution of the Flinto Case, I received, in January 2022, a notification from the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome concerning criminal proceeding No. 5533/2018, arising from a complaint filed by the company itself in 2018.
But what did the rules governing the Good Offices establish?
π NCP BRAZIL'S RULES OF PROCEDURE!
NCP Brazil's Rules of Procedure for Specific Instances, dated February 2020, established principles and rules for handling disputes involving multinational enterprises.
Among them were:
πΉ Good faith: genuine engagement by the parties in seeking a solution to the issues raised.
πΉ Dialogue: bringing the parties closer together to reach a consensual resolution.
πΉ Peaceful and neutral mediation: identifying areas of agreement while respecting the voluntary nature of the procedure.
πΉ Cooperation: constructive participation by the parties in an effort to overcome their differences.
These were not merely words. They were the principles intended to guide the parties' participation in the procedure!
π· BUT THERE WAS A FUNDAMENTAL QUESTION!
The Rules of Procedure themselves clarified, in Section 3.6(d), that the Good Offices did not exclude the jurisdiction of the courts.
Therefore, the existence of parallel judicial proceedings did not, in itself, constitute an automatic violation of NCP Brazil's rules.
But does that mean that any conduct during mediation would necessarily be consistent with the principles of good faith and dialogue?
That is the question!
In September 2021, Eni had agreed to participate in the Good Offices.
In October, the mediators were nominated and approved.
In December, the parties were discussing the mediation work plan.
And in that very same month, the Rome Public Prosecutor's Office issued a criminal notification relating to a complaint filed by Eni against me!
π WHAT DID THE RULES SAY ABOUT THE PURPOSE OF THE GOOD OFFICES?
Section 6.1 established that NCP Brazil would seek to facilitate dialogue to help the parties reach a mutually agreed resolution of the issues raised.
Section 6.9 provided for the preparation of a work plan, including objectives, deadlines, communication arrangements, and confidentiality commitments.
The purpose was to build a solution, not deepen the conflict!
And here lies the paradox:
π How can Eni's participation in a procedure designed to resolve a dispute consensually be reconciled with the initiation of criminal proceedings against the whistleblower, concerning his public statements about the very same case?
I am not claiming that the Rules of Procedure prohibited the existence of those proceedings.
I am questioning whether Eni's corporate conduct was consistent with the principles underlying its participation in the Good Offices!
π· AND WHAT ABOUT THE TIMING OF THE CRIMINAL NOTIFICATION?
There was another circumstance that deserves scrutiny.
In the civil proceedings initiated in 2010 and 2017, the Italian judicial authorities had used formal international judicial cooperation channels to serve documents in Brazil.
Yet, in December 2021, while the Good Offices were underway, the criminal notification was sent directly to my home by international registered mail.
The acknowledgment of receipt was signed by my condominium's doorman, and the criminal proceedings subsequently continued.
π Why was a different and seemingly more direct procedure adopted at precisely that stage of the dispute?
π Was the use of direct registered mail merely a procedural choice, or did it serve to accelerate the notification of the whistleblower while the Good Offices were underway?
And, considering that Eni was the company that had filed the criminal complaint:
π Did Eni have any involvement in the choice or timing of that notification procedure?
I do not have evidence establishing such involvement. But the circumstances raise questions that, in my view, deserve a transparent and documented explanation.
π· GOOD FAITH SHOULD NOT BE MERELY A FORMAL COMMITMENT!
For a multinational company that publicly declares its commitment to ethics, integrity, and whistleblower protection, participation in a mediation process should represent a genuine opportunity for dialogue.
Yet, while I was seeking a consensual resolution, I was also facing criminal proceedings arising from a complaint filed by that very same company.
Was this a practical demonstration of Eni's commitment to dialogue and responsible business conduct?
The manner in which the criminal notification was delivered also raised concerns about compliance with the judicial cooperation procedures between Brazil and Italy.
I therefore decided to seek official clarification.
And the response from Brazil's Office of the Prosecutor General revealed information that deserves to be known!
π΄ ENI SHOULD AUTHORIZE A TRULY INDEPENDENT, IMPARTIAL, AND TRANSPARENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE FLINTO CASE!
π· NEXT EPISODE: WHAT DID BRAZIL'S OFFICE OF THE PROSECUTOR GENERAL REVEAL ABOUT THE ITALIAN NOTIFICATION?
❎ Learn more:
1️⃣ NCP Brazil's Rules of Procedure for Specific Instances (Feb 2020)
2️⃣ Criminal notification issued by the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome (Dec 9, 2021):
πΉ Original document in Italian
πΉ English translation




