Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Ep115 - Mediation or intimidation?


πŸ“… December 2021 – January 2022 | Brazil — Italy

πŸ”· Is it possible to negotiate a consensual resolution with a multinational company while that very same company initiates criminal proceedings against you in another country?

That was precisely the situation I faced during the Good Offices conducted by Brazil's National Contact Point (NCP Brazil), under the OECD - OCDE Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises.

While Eni was participating in a mediation process aimed at reaching a consensual resolution of the Flinto Case, I received, in January 2022, a notification from the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome concerning criminal proceeding No. 5533/2018, arising from a complaint filed by the company itself in 2018.

But what did the rules governing the Good Offices establish?

πŸ“Œ NCP BRAZIL'S RULES OF PROCEDURE!

NCP Brazil's Rules of Procedure for Specific Instances, dated February 2020, established principles and rules for handling disputes involving multinational enterprises.
Among them were:

πŸ”Ή Good faith: genuine engagement by the parties in seeking a solution to the issues raised.

πŸ”Ή Dialogue: bringing the parties closer together to reach a consensual resolution.

πŸ”Ή Peaceful and neutral mediation: identifying areas of agreement while respecting the voluntary nature of the procedure.

πŸ”Ή Cooperation: constructive participation by the parties in an effort to overcome their differences.

These were not merely words. They were the principles intended to guide the parties' participation in the procedure!

πŸ”· BUT THERE WAS A FUNDAMENTAL QUESTION!

The Rules of Procedure themselves clarified, in Section 3.6(d), that the Good Offices did not exclude the jurisdiction of the courts.

Therefore, the existence of parallel judicial proceedings did not, in itself, constitute an automatic violation of NCP Brazil's rules.

But does that mean that any conduct during mediation would necessarily be consistent with the principles of good faith and dialogue?

That is the question!

In September 2021, Eni had agreed to participate in the Good Offices.

In October, the mediators were nominated and approved.

In December, the parties were discussing the mediation work plan.

And in that very same month, the Rome Public Prosecutor's Office issued a criminal notification relating to a complaint filed by Eni against me!

πŸ“Œ WHAT DID THE RULES SAY ABOUT THE PURPOSE OF THE GOOD OFFICES?

Section 6.1 established that NCP Brazil would seek to facilitate dialogue to help the parties reach a mutually agreed resolution of the issues raised.

Section 6.9 provided for the preparation of a work plan, including objectives, deadlines, communication arrangements, and confidentiality commitments.

The purpose was to build a solution, not deepen the conflict!

And here lies the paradox:

πŸ“Œ How can Eni's participation in a procedure designed to resolve a dispute consensually be reconciled with the initiation of criminal proceedings against the whistleblower, concerning his public statements about the very same case?

I am not claiming that the Rules of Procedure prohibited the existence of those proceedings.

I am questioning whether Eni's corporate conduct was consistent with the principles underlying its participation in the Good Offices!

πŸ”· AND WHAT ABOUT THE TIMING OF THE CRIMINAL NOTIFICATION?

There was another circumstance that deserves scrutiny.

In the civil proceedings initiated in 2010 and 2017, the Italian judicial authorities had used formal international judicial cooperation channels to serve documents in Brazil.

Yet, in December 2021, while the Good Offices were underway, the criminal notification was sent directly to my home by international registered mail.

The acknowledgment of receipt was signed by my condominium's doorman, and the criminal proceedings subsequently continued.

πŸ“Œ Why was a different and seemingly more direct procedure adopted at precisely that stage of the dispute?

πŸ“Œ Was the use of direct registered mail merely a procedural choice, or did it serve to accelerate the notification of the whistleblower while the Good Offices were underway?

And, considering that Eni was the company that had filed the criminal complaint:

πŸ“Œ Did Eni have any involvement in the choice or timing of that notification procedure?

I do not have evidence establishing such involvement. But the circumstances raise questions that, in my view, deserve a transparent and documented explanation.

πŸ”· GOOD FAITH SHOULD NOT BE MERELY A FORMAL COMMITMENT!

For a multinational company that publicly declares its commitment to ethics, integrity, and whistleblower protection, participation in a mediation process should represent a genuine opportunity for dialogue.

Yet, while I was seeking a consensual resolution, I was also facing criminal proceedings arising from a complaint filed by that very same company.

Was this a practical demonstration of Eni's commitment to dialogue and responsible business conduct?

The manner in which the criminal notification was delivered also raised concerns about compliance with the judicial cooperation procedures between Brazil and Italy.

I therefore decided to seek official clarification.

And the response from Brazil's Office of the Prosecutor General revealed information that deserves to be known!


πŸ”΄ ENI SHOULD AUTHORIZE A TRULY INDEPENDENT, IMPARTIAL, AND TRANSPARENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE FLINTO CASE!


πŸ”· NEXT EPISODE: WHAT DID BRAZIL'S OFFICE OF THE PROSECUTOR GENERAL REVEAL ABOUT THE ITALIAN NOTIFICATION?


❎ Learn more:

1️⃣ NCP Brazil's Rules of Procedure for Specific Instances (Feb 2020)

2️⃣ Criminal notification issued by the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome (Dec 9, 2021):
πŸ”Ή Original document in Italian
πŸ”Ή English translation

Monday, November 16, 2026

Ep114 - Three cases. One question.


πŸ“… 2010–2022 | Rome, Italy — Campinas, Brazil

πŸ”· Why did the Italian judicial authorities use different procedures to notify the same Brazilian citizen in legal proceedings involving Eni?

In 2010, one procedure.

In 2017, the same institutional approach.

But in December 2021, something changed!

In the previous episode, I presented the correspondence sent by the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome, which I received at my home in Campinas in January 2022, concerning criminal proceeding No. 5533/2018, arising from a criminal complaint filed by Eni.

The notification was written in Italian, although it mentioned a Portuguese translation that was not included in the correspondence I received.

Furthermore, the acknowledgment of receipt had been signed by the doorman of the condominium building where I live.

But why did that correspondence raise so many questions?

πŸ“Œ 2010 — THE ITALIAN JUDICIAL AUTHORITIES REQUEST BRAZIL'S COOPERATION!

On June 11, 2010, the Presidency of the Court of Appeal of Rome sent a formal request to the Brazilian Ministry of Justice to serve judicial documents on the Brazilian Institute of Ethics in Business (Instituto Brasileiro de Γ‰tica nos NegΓ³cios) in legal proceedings initiated by Eni.

The document expressly requested the involvement of the Brazilian authorities and stated that an official Portuguese translation of the judicial document was attached.

The Italian judicial authorities formally resorted to international judicial cooperation channels!

πŸ“Œ 2017 — THE SAME PROCEDURE IS REPEATED!

Seven years later, in another lawsuit filed by Eni, the Italian judicial authorities once again used the official cooperation channels with Brazil.

Documents dated November and December 2017 record the involvement of the Court of Appeal of Rome and the Italian Ministry of Justice, expressly referring to the bilateral convention on judicial assistance in civil matters between Brazil and Italy.

Two civil lawsuits. Two formal international judicial cooperation procedures!

πŸ”· DECEMBER 2021 — WHY WAS THE PROCEDURE DIFFERENT?

This time, in criminal proceeding No. 5533/2018, the communication was sent directly to my address in Brazil by international registered mail.

Without the Portuguese translation mentioned in the document, and with the acknowledgment of receipt signed by the condominium doorman!

It is important to note that the previous proceedings were civil, whereas the 2021 proceeding was criminal.

However, Brazil and Italy also have a Treaty on Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters, promulgated in Brazil by Decree No. 862 of July 9, 1993.

Therefore, one question needed to be answered:

✅ Did the criminal notification sent directly to my home comply with the procedures established under the bilateral treaty between the two countries?

It was precisely this question that led me to seek clarification from the competent Brazilian authorities.

πŸ”· AND THERE WAS ANOTHER PARTICULARLY INTRIGUING CIRCUMSTANCE!

When the notification was sent, Eni and I were already participating in the Good Offices conducted by Brazil's National Contact Point (NCP Brazil), under the OECD - OCDE Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises!

On one side, an attempt to reach a consensual resolution.

On the other, criminal proceedings arising from a complaint filed by the very same company against the whistleblower.

How can these two situations be reconciled?

This question deserves a closer examination, particularly in light of the principles of good faith and dialogue established by NCP Brazil.

And that is exactly what the next episode will address!


πŸ”΄ ENI SHOULD AUTHORIZE A TRULY INDEPENDENT, IMPARTIAL, AND TRANSPARENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE FLINTO CASE!


πŸ”· NEXT EPISODE: WAS ENI'S CONDUCT CONSISTENT WITH THE RULES GOVERNING THE GOOD OFFICES?


❎ Learn more:

1️⃣ Request for judicial assistance from the Court of Appeal of Rome (June 2010):
πŸ”Ή Original document in Italian
πŸ”Ή English translation

2️⃣ Judicial assistance correspondence between Italy and Brazil (November and December 2017):
πŸ”Ή Original documents in Italian
πŸ”Ή English translation

3️⃣ Criminal notification sent by the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome (December 2021):
πŸ”Ή Original document in Italian
πŸ”Ή English translation

Friday, November 13, 2026

Ep113 - An unexpected letter from Rome!


πŸ“… January 2022 | Rome, Italy — Campinas, Brazil

πŸ”· Have you ever imagined receiving, at your home in Brazil, a registered letter from the Rome Public Prosecutor's Office, written in Italian, requiring you to elect a domicile in Italy within 30 days?

Now imagine this happening while you are participating in a consensual dispute resolution process with the very company responsible for filing the criminal complaint, conducted by Brazil's National Contact Point (NCP Brazil), under the OECD framework!

That is exactly what happened to me in early 2022.

πŸ“Œ An unexpected letter from Rome!

In January 2022, I was surprised to receive an international registered letter, with acknowledgment of receipt, sent by the Procura della Repubblica presso il Tribunale Ordinario di Roma — the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome.
The envelope identified criminal proceeding No. 5533/2018.

The correspondence contained a notification abroad (Notificazioni all'Estero), dated December 9, 2021, requiring me to declare or elect a domicile in Italian territory within 30 days.

If I failed to comply, future notifications could be served on my appointed lawyer or, in the absence of one, on a court-appointed defense attorney.

But there was something deeply strange about that correspondence!

πŸ”· The notification was written only in Italian!
Although the document itself stated that a Portuguese translation was attached, the correspondence I received did not contain that translation!

And there was another detail: since I live in a condominium building, the acknowledgment of receipt for the registered letter was signed by the doorman.

In other words, a communication concerning criminal proceedings initiated in Italy against a Brazilian citizen residing in Brazil was delivered directly to the reception desk of the building where I live.

Without my having received the notification translated into my own language!

πŸ“Œ Why did I initially suspect that the correspondence was fake?

Because this was not the first time Eni had resorted to the Italian courts against me or the Brazilian Institute of Ethics in Business (Instituto Brasileiro de Γ‰tica nos NegΓ³cios).

In the legal proceedings initiated in 2010 and 2017, service of process had involved formal international judicial cooperation mechanisms between Brazil and Italy, including documents in Italian accompanied by Portuguese translations.

Why, then, was the Rome Public Prosecutor's Office using a different procedure?

πŸ”· And what did I discover when I examined the documentation?

The correspondence was related to a criminal complaint filed by Eni in 2018, concerning my public statements about the Flinto Case and the publication of information on the ENI'S WAY website.

The proceeding had been registered under No. 5533/2018, but the notification I received was not issued until December 2021.

And here is a particularly significant circumstance!

At that very moment, Eni and I were participating in the Good Offices conducted by NCP Brazil, seeking a possible consensual solution to a dispute that had already lasted more than two decades!

While a mediation initiative was underway in Brazil, I was receiving a communication from Italy concerning criminal proceedings arising from a complaint filed by the very same company.

What a paradox!

On one side, a multinational company participating in a consensual dispute resolution process under the OECD - OCDE Guidelines.

On the other, the whistleblower receiving an international criminal notification under circumstances that raised serious questions about compliance with judicial cooperation mechanisms between the two countries.

πŸ“Œ And where does the Judicial Cooperation Treaty between Brazil and Italy come into play?

Brazil and Italy have a bilateral treaty on judicial cooperation in criminal matters, promulgated in Brazil by Decree No. 862 of July 9, 1993.

Given the circumstances surrounding the receipt of the letter, I began questioning whether the notification had complied with the applicable international procedures.

After all, why was a criminal notification sent directly to my home, without a Portuguese translation being provided to me, when Eni's previous legal proceedings had followed formal judicial cooperation procedures?

And, most importantly:

Had the Rome Public Prosecutor's Office fully complied with the provisions of the bilateral treaty between Brazil and Italy?

πŸ”· A question that could not remain unanswered!

I decided to seek answers from the competent Brazilian authorities.

What I subsequently discovered made this story even more troubling.

Because the issue was no longer merely my interpretation of a letter received at home. It came to involve official communications concerning the need to comply with the international treaty!

And those communications will be presented in the upcoming episodes of this documentary series.

πŸ”· Eni, an unavoidable question!

How can the company's participation in a consensual dispute resolution process before NCP Brazil be reconciled with the existence of criminal proceedings against the same whistleblower in another country?

Is this how a company demonstrates its commitment to dialogue, whistleblower protection, and the responsible resolution of disputes?

After 25 years of questioning the irregularities I reported in 2001 and the retaliation that followed, I continue to demand that the facts be examined through a truly independent investigation.

And I continue to question why Eni's response to my reports of misconduct has so often involved the courts, rather than an independent investigation into the facts originally reported!


πŸ”΄ INSTEAD, ENI SHOULD AUTHORIZE A TRULY INDEPENDENT, IMPARTIAL, AND TRANSPARENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE FLINTO CASE!


πŸ”· NEXT EPISODE: WHY DID ITALY USE DIFFERENT PROCEDURES TO NOTIFY THE SAME WHISTLEBLOWER?



❎ Learn more:

1️⃣ Registered letter sent by the Rome Public Prosecutor's Office — December 2021:
πŸ”Ή Original envelope

2️⃣ Notification Abroad (Notificazioni all'Estero) — December 9, 2021:
πŸ”Ή Original document in Italian
πŸ”Ή English translation

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Ep112 - Eni, what would you answer?


πŸ“… November 12, 2026 | 25 Years of the Flinto Case

πŸ”· Eni, after more than 110 episodes of the ENI’S WAY — 25 YEARS OF TRUTH campaign, what would you answer if your stakeholders, including shareholders, requested clarification about the Flinto Case?

This question does not come out of nowhere.

In recent episodes, I have presented documents showing that different institutions requested explanations from Eni about my case.

The AIIA | Associazione Italiana Internal Auditors, the Presidency of the Italian Republic, CDP Cassa Depositi e Prestiti, the Italian Embassy in Brazil, and the WBCSD – World Business Council for Sustainable Development are among the key players in this documentary series.

And we must not forget two extraordinary facts:

πŸ“š The Flinto Case was featured in the Italian bestseller Eni: The Parallel State (2016), the first work of investigative journalism about the Italian oil giant.

πŸ›️ Mauro Meggiolaro, a critical shareholder representing Fondazione Finanza Etica, raised questions about the Flinto Case at four Eni Annual General Meetings (2017, 2018, 2020, and 2021)! What a paradox! A case featured in a bestseller and brought before the company’s own shareholders at four Annual General Meetings still awaits the independent investigation I have been demanding!

πŸ“Œ And how did Eni respond to these requests for clarification?

Repeatedly, it resorted to what I have come to call its “Corporate Narrative”: a lengthy account of my dismissal, the lawsuits bearing characteristics of SLAPPs, my public statements, and ENI’S WAY.

Much about the whistleblower. Little about the reported misconduct.

πŸ”· But which Eni are we talking about, exactly?

The Eni that has a Code of Ethics?

The Eni that maintains a Whistleblowing Policy and claims to protect those who report misconduct?

The Eni that holds ISO 37301:2021 certification (ISO - International Organization for Standardization) the international standard for compliance management systems?

The Eni that participates in the UN Global Compact Network Italia and holds Global Compact LEAD recognition?

The Eni that declares its commitment to the OECD - OCDE Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises?

Or the Eni that recognizes the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs), including Principle 12, which addresses internationally recognized human rights, encompassing protection against attacks on honor and reputation under Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights?

πŸ”· So many declarations. So many commitments. So many policies. So many pages devoted to ethics and integrity. In theory, a true benchmark in corporate governance!

But there is one question that none of these corporate documents can answer on its own:
What happens when a whistleblower demands that these commitments be applied to a real case?

In my case, the answer has been a 25-year battle.

I reported irregularities at Agip do Brasil in 2001. I was dismissed. I suffered retaliation. I faced lawsuits brought by Eni. I approached Boards of Directors, shareholders, international organizations, and public authorities.

My case was featured in an Italian bestseller and raised at four Eni Annual General Meetings.
And throughout all these years, I have continued to demand something that should be perfectly normal for a company that proclaims so many commitments to integrity:

A truly independent, impartial, and transparent investigation into the reported misconduct and the retaliation I suffered!

πŸ“Œ Now, let us imagine a very simple situation.

An institutional shareholder, an investor, an international organization, a public authority, or any other stakeholder decides to submit a request for clarification to Eni.

They do not ask about the bestseller Eni: The Parallel State.

They do not ask about the four Annual General Meetings at which the Flinto Case was questioned.

They do not ask about ENI’S WAY.

They do not ask how many emails I sent or how many times I criticized the company.

They ask only the following:

1️⃣ CODE OF ETHICS: Which provisions of Eni’s Code of Ethics were actually applied to investigate the irregularities reported by Douglas Linares Flinto in 2001?

2️⃣ WHISTLEBLOWING: If Eni claims to protect whistleblowers against retaliation, what concrete measures did it take to investigate the allegations of retaliation raised in the Flinto Case?

3️⃣ ISO 37301:2021: How does Eni demonstrate the conformity of its compliance management system in handling this case, particularly regarding impartiality, independence, and the effectiveness of the investigation?

4️⃣ UN GLOBAL COMPACT: How does Eni reconcile its public commitments to ethics, human rights, and integrity with the absence of disclosed findings from an independent investigation into the Flinto Case?

5️⃣ OECD GUIDELINES: How does Eni explain its decision to withdraw from the Good Offices conducted by NCP Brazil in March 2022, after having agreed to participate in the proceedings?

6️⃣ UNGP 31: How does Eni’s handling of the Flinto Case meet the criteria of legitimacy, accessibility, predictability, equitability, transparency, and rights compatibility established for effective grievance mechanisms?

πŸ”· Eni, six questions. Six opportunities to demonstrate that your words match your actions!

And please, this time there would be no need to repeat the story of my dismissal, mention the lawsuits, or portray my communications as a campaign against the company.

Your stakeholders do not need yet another narrative about the whistleblower. They need answers about the reported misconduct!

Because a company does not demonstrate its integrity merely by publishing policies, joining international initiatives, or displaying certifications.

It demonstrates integrity when its commitments are put to the test. Especially when the facts are uncomfortable.

πŸ“Œ And here lies the great irony of this story:

Eni has a Code of Ethics, a Whistleblowing Policy, compliance structures, international certification, and commitments to the OECD and the United Nations.

The Flinto Case has been featured in an Italian bestseller, questioned at four Annual General Meetings, and brought to the attention of international institutions and authorities.

Yet, after 25 years, I am still asking the company to do what its own institutional commitments proclaim! There is no shortage of policies. No shortage of commitments. No shortage of questions. What is missing are answers backed by evidence of an independent investigation!

πŸ”· So, Eni, the question remains: πŸ“Œ IF YOUR STAKEHOLDERS, INCLUDING SHAREHOLDERS, REQUESTED THESE CLARIFICATIONS TODAY, WHAT WOULD YOU ANSWER?

Another version of your corporate narrative?

Or, finally, documents, evidence, and findings from a truly independent investigation?


πŸ”΄ INSTEAD, ENI SHOULD AUTHORIZE A TRULY INDEPENDENT, IMPARTIAL, AND TRANSPARENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE FLINTO CASE!


πŸ”· NEXT EPISODE: WHEN THE ROME PUBLIC PROSECUTOR’S OFFICE FAILED TO COMPLY WITH INTERNATIONAL TREATIES BETWEEN ITALY AND BRAZIL WHEN SUMMONING ME IN BRAZIL!

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Ep111 - When WBCSD questioned Eni


πŸ“… May 25, 2021 | Geneva, Switzerland

πŸ”· When one of the world's most important business organizations dedicated to sustainability received a complaint about the Flinto Case, what did it do?

In May 2021, I contacted Peter Bakker, President and CEO of the WBCSD – World Business Council for Sustainable Development, an international organization bringing together major companies committed to sustainable development, including Eni.

My message questioned the gap between the company's public commitments to ethics, transparency, and integrity and its conduct regarding the irregularities I reported in 2001, when I worked at Agip do Brasil.

At the time, I emphasized that my battle with the Italian oil giant was approaching 20 years, during which different Eni Chairmen and Boards of Directors had become aware of the Flinto Case.

I also mentioned the proposal for an amicable settlement requested by Eni itself in November 2020 through the Italian Ambassador to Brazil, the monitoring of the case by NCP Brazil (OECD - OCDE), and the absence of a truly independent, impartial, and transparent investigation into the facts originally reported.

πŸ“Œ And how did the WBCSD react?

On May 25, 2021, Federico Merlo, Managing Director & Senior Management Team at the WBCSD (currently at PwC), sent a message to Stefano Goberti, an Eni executive, copying Peter Bakker and other professionals from the organization and the company.

The WBCSD representative explained that Peter Bakker had received a communication from me describing an approximately two-decade-long dispute with Eni.

He then made a straightforward request:

πŸ“Œ Could Eni provide more information about the background of the case and clarify whether any action was being taken to resolve it?

The executive also emphasized that the WBCSD's objective was to understand the situation without making any prior judgment about the merits of the dispute.

πŸ”· Yet another stakeholder requesting clarification from Eni!

This request was not an isolated incident.

Before that, Eni had already received inquiries from the AIIA | Associazione Italiana Internal Auditors, critical shareholders, CDP Cassa Depositi e Prestiti, and the Italian Embassy in Brazil.

And these initiatives had one element in common: institutions and stakeholder representatives were seeking to understand what had actually happened in the Flinto Case and what measures the company had taken.

πŸ“Œ But what did Eni tell the WBCSD?

Documents that later came to my attention revealed that Eni repeatedly used a "Corporate Narrative" in its responses to requests for clarification.

Instead of presenting an independent investigation into the irregularities reported in 2001 and the retaliation that followed, the company focused its arguments on the whistleblower's actions, the lawsuits, and allegations that my communications were damaging its reputation.

This narrative eventually incorporated references to discussions concerning a possible amicable settlement and the monitoring of the Flinto Case by NCP Brazil.

The Corporate Narrative could change its tone. But the essential question remained unanswered: where were the results of an independent investigation into the reported facts?

πŸ”· Corporate sustainability cannot exist only in words!

The WBCSD promotes commitments related to sustainability and corporate responsibility. But these commitments must also be demonstrated in how companies handle complaints, respect their stakeholders, and protect those who report potential irregularities.

After all, what is the point of a company proclaiming values of ethics, transparency, and integrity if, when questioned about the conduct of its executives, it fails to provide explanations supported by verifiable evidence?

And one more question: did the WBCSD consider Eni's explanations satisfactory?


πŸ”΄ INSTEAD, ENI SHOULD AUTHORIZE A TRULY INDEPENDENT, IMPARTIAL, AND TRANSPARENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE FLINTO CASE!


πŸ”· NEXT EPISODE: AFTER MORE THAN 110 EPISODES, WHAT WOULD ENI SAY TO ITS STAKEHOLDERS?



❎ Learn more:

1️⃣ Correspondence between the WBCSD and Eni — May 25, 2021:
πŸ”Ή Original document in English